Amyloidosis is the result of various, differently approachable diseases. It is vital to subtype the amyloid deposits in order to establish and finally treat the underlying disease properly. Besides the classical staining with Congo red, further procedures like immunohistochemical staining are needed for classification. Here, we present a more accurate approach using Congo red/immunohistochemical double staining easily applicable in routine diagnostics. Modifications of the Congo red staining technique and the immunohistochemical procedures were needed in order to combine both staining procedures on one slide. The evaluation was done using conventional light and fluorescence microscopy. By shortening the staining time for Congo red to 10 s and by modification regarding endogenous peroxidase blockage, accurate results could be obtained for evaluating the Congo red/immunohistochemistry double staining using a fluorescence microscope. Sections of 2 μm instead of 4 μm thickness were superior for evaluation, since they increased staining specificity. The combination of Congo red and immunohistochemistry as in situ double staining on one slide is a feasible approach in the diagnosis of amyloidosis. It allows focusing on the fluorescent Congo red-positive areas when evaluating immunohistochemistry, thus avoiding signing out false-positive results. Additionally, it increases the signal-to-noise ratio of the immunohistochemically stained sections on conventional microscopy.